SimplyStamps.com Reviews
SimplyStamps.com has an overall rating of 4.6 based on 33 reviews. Customer feedback on SimplyStamps.com is mixed.
33 reviews
5 Stars
26
4 Stars
1
3 Stars
6
2 Stars
0
1 Star
0
How would you rate SimplyStamps.com?
All SimplyStamps.com Reviews (33)
ryan.Lillpop
May 24, 2026
"Arrived way sooner than I thought"
I was surprised by how fast it got here. Everything went smoothly with no issues, so I’d definitely recommend it if you’re looking for something quick and easy.
0
Reply
hello_rick527
May 22, 2026
"Proof approval was easy"
I got my proof back quickly, and approving it was really straightforward. As far as I could tell, everything looked right, so I was able to approve it without any hassle
0
Reply
JorgeRowe
May 11, 2026
"Clean ink and no smudging"
I ordered my stamp from simplystamps.com, the ink turned out way better than I thought it would. It comes out clean every time, not faded or blotchy, even after I’ve used it a lot. It also dries fast, so I’m not accidentally smearing it across papers. Just from how consistent it is, I’m guessing they put some real care into the quality. I’m really happy with it.
0
Reply
cherylbowles1842
May 07, 2026
"Pretty easy to make my stamp"
I wasn’t sure how the design part was going to go, but it turned out to be really straightforward. I just uploaded my logo, adjusted it a little, and could preview it right away. It didn’t take much time, and everything was clear enough that I didn’t need any help. Smooth overall
0
Reply
CherylSinegal_37
May 04, 2026
"Clear as heck right out of the box"
I ordered a custom stamp and figured the tiny text might come out looking like some blurry little disaster, because that’s usually how these things go. But nope, this thing stamped super clear right out of the box, even on plain copy paper.
No smudgy edges, no weird ink blobs, none of that cheap-stamp nonsense. The letters are sharp, I’ve used it a bunch this week, and it still looks just as good. Happy with it, not gonna lie
No smudgy edges, no weird ink blobs, none of that cheap-stamp nonsense. The letters are sharp, I’ve used it a bunch this week, and it still looks just as good. Happy with it, not gonna lie
0
Reply
sam_Reynolds73
May 02, 2026
"Consistently clean stamp"
I’m picky about little patterns in how things print, and this stamp has been coming out nice and even every time I use it. The lines look clean, the quality feels good, and it has a solid feel in the hand. Really happy with how it turned out...
0
Reply
HEGGE
April 29, 2026
"I used Simply Stamps again because I could..."
I used Simply Stamps again because I could just reorder my old stamp without having to start from scratch. That was handy and definitely saved me some time. The site was okay to use, though it did take me a minute to find what I needed. Shipping felt just a little slow for my timeline, but the stamp turned out fine. Overall, not bad, just nothing especially amazing
0
Reply
Jorge-watson
April 29, 2026
"Discount worked good for me"
I used a promo code when I ordered my stamps and it actually took off a nice amount, which was good to see. The checkout part was easy also, no problems or weird stuff happened.
0
Reply
justin_Amyotte85
April 24, 2026
"Problem was resolved, just took a little while"
I had an issue with my stamp order, and to be fair, support did get it fixed in the end. It just took longer than I was hoping, which was a bit frustrating. Overall, not a bad experience, but I think the process could’ve been a little quicker
0
Reply
andrea_Abernathy05
April 22, 2026
"Decent selection, but not the best first impression"
My first impression wasn’t great because there were just so many stamp options that it felt kind of overwhelming. I’m glad they have a good selection, but it took me a while to narrow things down and find the one I actually needed.
0
Reply
james1981
April 17, 2026
"Works great and makes mailing easier"
This self-inking stamp has been working really well for me. The stamp comes out clean every time and, as you’d expect, it doesn’t dry out quickly if you’re using it normally. It’s made handling my mail stuff a lot easier.
0
Reply
Jeff.williamson
April 11, 2026
"Good stamp for the price, but communication could be clearer"
I ordered a custom stamp from simplystamps.com and overall I’m happy with it. The price was better than a few other sites I looked at, and the stamp itself came out clean and does exactly what I needed. Shipping was quick too. My only real annoyance was that some of the communication wasn’t super clear, so I wasn’t always sure what stage the order was in. Still, for the price and quality, I’d probably order from them again...
0
Reply
oscar_Robinson70
March 25, 2026
"The stamp itself turned out great, so I..."
The stamp itself turned out great, so I don’t have any complaints there. For me, the only issue was the tracking. It still showed my order as processing even after it had already shipped, and then it updated late. It wasn’t a major problem, but I personally found it a bit frustrating since I wasn’t sure when it was actually going to arrive
0
Reply
hello_doris922
March 24, 2026
"Arrived looking great"
The box showed up in perfect condition, which always gives me a good first impression. The packaging felt really sturdy and well done, like they actually took care to make sure everything arrived safely.
0
Reply
James_hollie81
March 18, 2026
"Took a little while to hear back"
They did get back to me, but, you know, it just took a bit longer than I was hoping
0
Reply
THOMAS
March 17, 2026
"I usually stick with another stamp brand because..."
I usually stick with another stamp brand because I’ve used them for years, so I wasn’t totally sure about trying Simply Stamps. But this one has been great. I use it every day at work, and after months it still stamps clean with no issues. Definitely made me rethink my usual go-to.
0
Reply
Sara_edwards79
March 16, 2026
"So many templates to choose from..."
There are so many templates to pick from... I had plenty of options and found something that worked for what I needed.
0
Reply
Tiffany_ornellas81
March 14, 2026
"My custom stamp turned out just right"
I’m really happy with how my custom stamp came out. The spelling was correct, and the layout looked exactly the way I had asked for.
0
Reply
DavidNewman
February 28, 2026
"Showed up sooner than I thought"
If I’m remembering right, this arrived faster than most things I’ve ordered lately. Shipping was really quick, which was a nice surprise. Thanks!
0
Reply
tina_Rutt04
February 24, 2026
"Stamp worked fine, but the pad hunt was annoying"
The stamp itself is totally fine and does what it’s supposed to, so no real complaints there. But wow, trying to figure out which replacement pad I needed was more of a hassle than I expected. They do have options, which is great, I guess, but it wasn’t super clear which one actually fit my stamp. Not a huge deal, but also kind of frustrating.
0
Reply
Have a question about SimplyStamps.com?
Log in to ask your SimplyStamps.com question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
